docs(#558): m-driver-pin-rollout — gate discharged, doc designed, PARKED at the quorum gate (D-13) - #685
Merged
Conversation
…KED at the quorum gate (D-13)
The `[BLOCKED-ON-EVIDENCE]` gate on the charter's m-driver-pin-rollout row is now
DISCHARGED by measurement: 5 pin lines in the V1 driver log, `DRIVER PIN FAILED` = 0
with its known-positive control firing, and fires 185/186/187 each pinned, started and
completed with charter records.
Gate 2 then corrected the item's scope before any designer ran. `nightly-lang-eval.sh`
is NOT a launchd entry point (no plist installed or in-repo, no crontab, no log — control:
`nightly-eval.plist` present in both locations), so the charter's five are four; and those
four split into repo-rooted (nightly-eval, os-rotation-filler) vs script-only
(mission-recovery, rig-watchdog, which have no REPO= and read zero repo artifacts). None of
the four spawns `claude` (0/0/0/0; mission-recovery's single hit is a comment, control
mission-control.sh = 24), so the charter's per-checkout human onboarding prerequisite
applies to zero of them — a question the charter explicitly asked to be measured.
Designer `claude:claude-fable-5` (rotation, two bounded passes) produced a 434-line doc
with 24 verification rows and found two things the controller had not, both confirmed
first-party: `mission-recovery.plist` injects MISSION_NAME=v1 at a 240s interval, so the
pin helper's default dir would have `checkout --force`d the LIVE V1 mission worktree every
four minutes under a running iteration; and `make test-launchd-drivers` is 9-passed/26-failed
rc=2 inside a pinned session versus 17/0 rc=0 with AILANG_DRIVER_*/MISSION_WORKDIR/MISSION_NAME
sanitized — the acceptance gate is red at base in exactly the environment the loop runs in.
Quorum BLOCKED twice, both reviewers present in both rounds, all four objections measured
rather than forwarded. Round 1's fetch-timeout objection had a false premise (the helper
already bounds the fetch via `_pin_bounded` at 120s) but correct substance (120s is 2x
rig-watchdog's 60s cadence); one bounded revision applied per-driver bounds plus a
non-vacuous AC. Round 2 blocked again, and measuring made both new objections WORSE than
filed:
V23 — `os-release-snapshot.sh` and `publish-unified-dashboard.sh` root themselves from
`$0`, not the caller's cwd, so the doc's `cwd=$REPO_DURABLE` data-continuity
strategy cannot work by construction. The reviewer's own proposed_fix presumes the
audit comes out clean; it does not, so applying it verbatim would have written a
false row into the document.
V24 — an automatic source-clone updater DOES exist: `os-rotation-filler.sh` git-pulls at
:197/398/426/458 every 45 minutes, which is why the clone reads 0 behind. That
refutes the objection's literal premise — and its conclusion survives for a worse
reason, because M2 pins that very filler, so the rollout would delete the only
automatic delivery path for every later milestone.
Both need a controller-invented resolution, which the narrow-refinement carve-out forbids,
so Standing rule 2 binds: PARKED needs-human-review with every measurement banked, and a
new one-word decision D-13 (A: exclude the filler / B: fast-forward inside pin-root.sh /
C: re-root durable writes through $AILANG_DRIVER_SRC).
Also fixes two bookkeeping defects in the loop's own records: the mission log's entry
counter had drifted (iteration 187 wrote `## 187`, colliding with iteration 185's entry),
and that entry omitted the words "Iteration 187", which is what made Gate 4's staleness
tell read 0 on a healthy log while its control read 1.
metered=$0.1778 (two quorum rounds x two present reviewers) against the $5 ceiling.
Co-Authored-By: Claude Opus 5 <noreply@anthropic.com>
|
sunholo-voight-kampff
deleted the
sprint/iter188-driver-pin-rollout-doc
branch
August 13, 2026 00:15
This file contains hidden or bidirectional Unicode text that may be interpreted or compiled differently than what appears below. To review, open the file in an editor that reveals hidden Unicode characters.
Learn more about bidirectional Unicode characters
Sign up for free
to join this conversation on GitHub.
Already have an account?
Sign in to comment
1 participant
Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.This suggestion is invalid because no changes were made to the code.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is closed.Suggestions cannot be applied while viewing a subset of changes.Only one suggestion per line can be applied in a batch.Add this suggestion to a batch that can be applied as a single commit.Applying suggestions on deleted lines is not supported.You must change the existing code in this line in order to create a valid suggestion.Outdated suggestions cannot be applied.This suggestion has been applied or marked resolved.Suggestions cannot be applied from pending reviews.Suggestions cannot be applied on multi-line comments.Suggestions cannot be applied while the pull request is queued to merge.Suggestion cannot be applied right now. Please check back later.
Iteration 188 record. Docs only — no code change; the deliverable is a design doc that parked at the quorum gate, plus the measurements that park it well.
The gate is discharged
The charter's
m-driver-pin-rolloutrow was tagged[BLOCKED-ON-EVIDENCE]pending "≥3 consecutive V1 fires logging the pin with a normal iteration completing". Measured, with controls: 5 pin lines in/tmp/ailang-mission-control.log,DRIVER PIN FAILED= 0 with its known-positive control firing, fires 185/186/187 each pinned → started → completed with charter records.Gate 2 corrected the item's scope before the designer ran
nightly-lang-eval.shis not a launchd entry point — no plist installed or in-repo, no crontab, no log (control:nightly-eval.plistin both locations). The charter's "five" is four.nightly-eval.sh:28,os-rotation-filler.sh:12) and script-only (mission-recovery.sh,rig-watchdog.sh— noREPO=, zero repo reads).claude(0/0/0/0;mission-recovery.sh:50is a comment, controlmission-control.sh= 24), so the charter's per-checkout human onboarding prerequisite applies to zero of them.Two findings the designer added, both confirmed first-party
dev.ailang.mission-recovery.plistinjectsMISSION_NAME=v1atStartInterval240, so the pin helper's default dir would havecheckout --forced the live V1 mission worktree every four minutes under a running iteration.make test-launchd-driversis 9-passed/26-failed rc=2 inside a pinned session vs 17/0 rc=0 withAILANG_DRIVER_*/MISSION_WORKDIR/MISSION_NAMEsanitized. CI is green only because CI's env is clean.Why it parks
Quorum BLOCKED ×2, both reviewers present both rounds, all four objections measured rather than forwarded. Round 2's two objections came back worse than filed:
os-release-snapshot.sh/publish-unified-dashboard.shroot themselves from$0, not cwd, so the doc's data-continuity strategy cannot work by construction — and the reviewer's ownproposed_fixpresumes an audit result that is false.os-rotation-filler.shgit-pulls every 45 min), refuting the literal premise — but M2 pins that very filler, so the rollout would delete the only delivery path for every later milestone.Both need a controller-invented resolution, which the narrow-refinement carve-out forbids → Standing rule 2 binds.
D-13asks Mark one word: (A) exclude the filler / (B) fast-forward insidepin-root.sh/ (C) re-root durable writes through$AILANG_DRIVER_SRC.metered=$0.1778against the$5ceiling.🤖 Generated with Claude Code