Skip to content

PR_26175_OWNER_054: add Alfa consolidated batch closeout plan #154

New issue

Have a question about this project? Sign up for a free GitHub account to open an issue and contact its maintainers and the community.

Sign up for GitHub

By clicking “Sign up for GitHub”, you agree to our terms of service and privacy statement. We’ll occasionally send you account related emails.

Already on GitHub? Sign in to your account

Closed
ToolboxAid wants to merge 1 commit into from
Closed

PR_26175_OWNER_054: add Alfa consolidated batch closeout plan #154

Show file tree
Hide file tree
Changes from all commits
Commits
Show all changes
1 commit
Select commit
File filter

Filter by extension

Filter by extension
Conversations
Failed to load comments.
Loading
Jump to
Jump to file
Failed to load files.
Loading
Diff view
Diff view
112 changes: 112 additions & 0 deletions docs_build/dev/reports/PR_26175_OWNER_054-alfa-consolidated-batch-closeout-plan.md
View file
Open in desktop
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -0,0 +1,112 @@
# PR_26175_OWNER_054 - Alfa Consolidated Batch Closeout Plan

## Executive Summary

PASS - Audit/report only. No PRs were merged, closed, or modified.

GitHub was used as authority for PR state. The old Alfa #96-#118 stack remains open as draft PRs, with every old PR based on another non-main Alfa stack branch. The consolidated replacement PRs #146, #148, #149, and #150 target `main`, but all refreshed as conflicting against current `main` after the latest governance/report merges.

Recommendation:

1. Merge consolidated PR #146 after resolving generated report conflicts and moving from draft to ready.
2. Do not merge consolidated PR #148 as-is; treat it as needs-owner-decision because it carries older Game Hub parent/child behavior that may be superseded by #149.
3. Merge consolidated PR #149 after resolving generated report conflicts and rechecking Game Hub behavior.
4. Merge consolidated PR #150 after resolving generated report conflicts and rechecking Idea Board behavior.
5. Close old PRs #96 through #118 as superseded after OWNER approves the consolidated merge/close batch.

## Consolidated PR Recommendations

| PR | Consolidated Scope | GitHub State | Mergeability Refresh | Recommendation | Blocker |
| --- | --- | --- | --- | --- | --- |
| #146 `PR_26175_ALFA_015` | Foundation runtime consolidation for #96-#101 | Open draft | Conflicting | Merge after conflict resolution | Generated report conflicts in `codex_changed_files.txt` and `codex_review.diff`; draft state; Playwright browser blocked by missing Chromium in PR validation. |
| #148 `PR_26175_ALFA_016` | Parent/child table consolidation for #103-#105 | Open draft | Conflicting | Needs OWNER decision; do not merge as-is | Generated report conflicts plus semantic risk: report describes Open Games parent-table identity and Game Summary child table, which may conflict with the later #149 two-child-row Game Hub direction. |
| #149 `PR_26175_ALFA_017` | Game Hub interaction consolidation for #107-#113 | Open draft | Conflicting | Merge after conflict resolution | Generated report conflicts; draft state; Playwright browser blocked by missing Chromium in PR validation. |
| #150 `PR_26175_ALFA_018` | Idea Board polish consolidation for #114-#116 | Open draft | Conflicting | Merge after conflict resolution | Generated report conflicts; draft state; Playwright browser blocked by missing Chromium in PR validation. |

## Recommended Merge Order

| Order | Action | Reason |
| --- | --- | --- |
| 1 | Resolve and merge #146 | Foundation/Game Journey persistence behavior is independent from the later Game Hub/Idea Board UI consolidation. |
| 2 | OWNER decision on #148 | #148 should either be recreated from current main or closed if #149 is the accepted replacement for Game Hub parent/child behavior. |
| 3 | Resolve and merge #149 | Carries the final current-main-safe Game Hub interaction direction and supersedes the old Batch C stack. |
| 4 | Resolve and merge #150 | Carries the final Idea Board status polish and can follow #149 to preserve the consolidated Alfa sequence. |

## Old Alfa PR Close Map

| Old PR | Old Title | Stack Area | Close Recommendation |
| --- | --- | --- | --- |
| #96 | `PR_26174_ALFA_002-game-hub-project-intake-display` | Foundation A | Close as superseded by #146 and current main direction. |
| #97 | `PR_26174_ALFA_003-game-hub-journey-bootstrap` | Foundation A | Close as superseded by #146 and current main direction. |
| #98 | `PR_26174_ALFA_004-game-hub-progress-count-model` | Foundation A | Close as superseded by #146 and current main direction. |
| #99 | `PR_26174_ALFA_005-idea-project-validation-polish` | Foundation A | Close as superseded by #146/#150 and current main direction. |
| #100 | `PR_26174_ALFA_006-game-hub-empty-and-error-states` | Foundation A | Close as superseded by #146 and current main direction. |
| #101 | `PR_26174_ALFA_007-game-journey-count-ui-polish` | Foundation A | Close as superseded by #146 and current main direction. |
| #102 | `PR_26174_ALFA_008-alpha-stack-final-validation` | Validation wrapper | Close as superseded; validation-wrapper-only PR should not merge. |
| #103 | `PR_26174_ALFA_009-game-hub-parent-child-table-layout` | Parent/child B | Close as superseded after OWNER decides #148 vs #149 final Game Hub shape. |
| #104 | `PR_26174_ALFA_010-game-hub-source-idea-child-table-polish` | Parent/child B | Close as superseded after OWNER decides #148 vs #149 final Game Hub shape. |
| #105 | `PR_26174_ALFA_011-game-hub-readiness-output-child-table` | Parent/child B | Close as superseded after OWNER decides #148 vs #149 final Game Hub shape. |
| #106 | `PR_26174_ALFA_012-game-hub-parent-child-final-validation` | Validation wrapper | Close as superseded; validation-wrapper-only PR should not merge. |
| #107 | `PR_26174_ALFA_013-game-hub-game-row-child-rows` | Interaction C | Close as superseded by #149. |
| #108 | `PR_26174_ALFA_014-game-hub-parent-columns-center` | Interaction C | Close as superseded by #149/current main. |
| #109 | `PR_26174_ALFA_015-game-hub-actions-and-setup-cleanup` | Interaction C | Close as superseded by #149/current main. |
| #110 | `PR_26174_ALFA_016-game-hub-row-edit-add-selected-state` | Interaction C | Close as superseded by #149/current main. |
| #111 | `PR_26174_ALFA_017-game-hub-guest-save-and-crew-cleanup` | Interaction C | Close as superseded by #149/current main. |
| #112 | `PR_26174_ALFA_018-game-selection-button-state` | Interaction C | Close as superseded by #149/current main. |
| #113 | `PR_26174_ALFA_019-game-hub-selected-button-and-crew-label` | Interaction C | Close as superseded by #149/current main. |
| #114 | `PR_26174_ALFA_020-game-hub-idea-board-cleanup` | Idea Board D | Close as superseded by #150/current main. |
| #115 | `PR_26174_ALFA_021-idea-board-status-filter-table-polish` | Idea Board D | Close as superseded by #150/current main. |
| #116 | `PR_26174_ALFA_022-idea-board-status-dropdown-fix` | Idea Board D | Close as superseded by #150/current main. |
| #117 | `PR_26174_ALFA_EOD-workstream-closeout` | EOD evidence | Close as superseded by consolidated closeout plan; archive as evidence only. |
| #118 | `PR_26174_ALFA_EOD-final-closeout` | EOD evidence | Close as superseded by consolidated closeout plan; archive as evidence only. |

## Blockers

| Blocker | Applies To | Detail |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Draft state | #146, #148, #149, #150 | All consolidated PRs are still draft and should not merge until OWNER marks them ready or explicitly approves draft merge handling. |
| Merge conflicts | #146, #148, #149, #150 | `gh pr view` refresh reported `CONFLICTING` for all four consolidated PRs. Non-destructive `git merge-tree` checks show generated report conflicts in `docs_build/dev/reports/codex_changed_files.txt` and `docs_build/dev/reports/codex_review.diff`. |
| Semantic conflict | #148 | #148 includes older Game Hub parent-child behavior that may be superseded by #149. OWNER should decide close/recreate/merge before any #148 action. |
| Browser validation unavailable | #146, #149, #150; likely #148 | Prior consolidated PR validation reports show Playwright blocked because local Chromium is missing. Do not install Chromium unless OWNER approves. |
| Old PR stack bases | #96-#118 | Every old PR is based on another historical non-main stack branch, making direct merge inappropriate even when GitHub reports `MERGEABLE` within that stale stack. |

## GitHub Authority Notes

- `gh pr view` was used for PR #96 through #118 and #146 through #150.
- Consolidated PR refresh command rechecked #146, #148, #149, and #150 after GitHub had time to update mergeability.
- Non-destructive `git merge-tree` was used only to identify conflict surfaces; no merge, close, or branch delete was performed.

## Requirement Checklist

| Requirement | Status | Notes |
| --- | --- | --- |
| Start from `main` | PASS | `main` was checked before work. |
| Hard stop if branch/worktree/sync invalid | PASS | Initial branch `main`, clean worktree, local/origin sync `0 0`; after `git pull --ff-only`, still `main`, clean, `0 0`. |
| Read all Project Instructions | PASS | All files under `docs_build/dev/ProjectInstructions/` were read. |
| Review consolidated Alfa PRs 015-018 | PASS | Reviewed #146, #148, #149, #150. |
| Map against old Alfa PRs #96-#118 | PASS | Old PR close map included above. |
| Recommend consolidated PR merge/hold/close action | PASS | Included above. |
| Identify blockers | PASS | Included above. |
| Do not merge PRs | PASS | No merge performed. |
| Do not close PRs | PASS | No closure performed. |
| Required reports and ZIP | PASS | `codex_review.diff`, `codex_changed_files.txt`, this report, and repo-structured ZIP are included. |

## Validation Lane

| Command | Status | Result |
| --- | --- | --- |
| `git pull --ff-only` | PASS | `main` fast-forwarded, then remained clean and synced. |
| `gh pr view #96-#118,#146-#150 --json ...` | PASS | GitHub-authority PR inventory collected. |
| `gh pr view #146,#148,#149,#150 --json mergeable` | PASS | Refreshed consolidated PR mergeability; all four reported `CONFLICTING`. |
| `git merge-tree` non-destructive checks | PASS | Identified report conflicts without merging. |
| Runtime code validation | N/A | Report-only PR; no runtime code changed. |

## Manual Validation Notes

- This plan intentionally does not resolve conflicts, mark PRs ready, close old PRs, merge consolidated PRs, or delete branches.
- Old PRs #96-#118 should be closed only after OWNER explicitly approves the close batch.
- Consolidated PR conflicts appear dominated by generated report files, but #148 requires a separate semantic decision because its Game Hub shape may no longer match the latest consolidated direction.

## Branch Validation

PASS - Work began from clean, synced `main`; implementation was made on `PR_26175_OWNER_054-alfa-consolidated-batch-closeout-plan`.
12 changes: 3 additions & 9 deletions docs_build/dev/reports/codex_changed_files.txt
View file
Open in desktop
Original file line number Diff line number Diff line change
@@ -1,9 +1,3 @@
# git status --short


# git diff --name-status main...HEAD
A docs_build/dev/reports/PR_26175_OWNER_049-governance-report-merge-batch.md

# git diff --stat main...HEAD
...6175_OWNER_049-governance-report-merge-batch.md | 128 +++++++++++++++++++++
1 file changed, 128 insertions(+)
docs_build/dev/reports/PR_26175_OWNER_054-alfa-consolidated-batch-closeout-plan.md
docs_build/dev/reports/codex_changed_files.txt
docs_build/dev/reports/codex_review.diff
Loading
Loading